Wednesday, 3 October 2012

Goldilocks and Predestination Paradox


Once upon a time Goldilocks was walking along the wide path through the forest, on her way to the house of the Three Bears. It was about six months or so after she had met them for the first time and they had all become great friends. Daddy Bear had emailed Goldilocks to ask if she could look after Baby Bear for a couple of hours whilst he and Mummy Bear went down to the Mall to buy Mummy Bear a special anniversary present.
 
Goldilocks was only too pleased to help out, so she had set off bright and early on a lovely summer’s morning to walk the two miles through the forest. She had probably gone about half way when she came upon a hare, who was walking in the same direction as she was, though somewhat slowly.
 
“Good Morning Mr Hare,” said Goldilocks, because she had been brought up properly and was always polite.
 
“Good Morning to you young lady,” replied the Hare, and the two began quite naturally to walk side by side, commenting on the weather, the greenness of the trees and the warmth of the Sun as it dropped its dappled light through the canopy.
 
After a few minutes Goldilocks was quiet for a moment but then said, “Mr Hare, I wonder if you would mind if I asked you a question?”
 
“Not at all”, replied the Hare. “Go ahead.”
 
“Could it be,” ventured Goldilocks, “that you are the same hare that once famously competed in a race with a tortoise – and lost?”
 
The hare flushed a little but replied, “I have to admit young lady that I am indeed that somewhat foolish hare, though in my defence I have to say that things have altered considerably since that event, which was several years ago.”
 
“How so?” Goldilocks quizzed, because although she was well brought up she was still naturally curious and of course quite young.
 
The hare stopped by a huge tree that had fallen in the winter gales and he rested against its trunk. Goldilocks sat beside him. “After that unfortunate experience, I began to realise that perhaps I didn’t know enough about life and that the time was right for me to seek out some education. As a result I enrolled in college and eventually achieved a degree and a certificate – not to mention a cap and a gown. Modesty forbids me from suggesting that I am now significantly wiser than I was back in those days,” he ventured, “but I don’t think that if the same race was run today, I would be likely to lose. In fact……” he began.
 
“Go on,” said Goldilocks, who was intrigued to know what was going through the hare’s mind.
 
“Well it has occurred to me that I may be able to prove how much I have changed thanks to my education. Do you like paradoxes young lady?”
 
“Indeed I do,” she replied, though in all honesty she wasn’t entirely sure what a paradox was.
 
“Then let’s have another race – this bright and beautiful morning. May I ask where you are going?”
 
“Certainly,” she replied. “I’m going to the cottage of the Three Bears, to look after Baby Bear.”
 
“In that case,” said the hare, you and I will have a race to the house of the Three Bears, but with a twist.” He twitched his whiskers. “I will not only beat you in the race, but I will also finish after you. How about that?”
 
Goldilocks was puzzled. “I don’t see how that could be possible,” she admitted, but I should like to see it all the same. When shall we begin?”
 
“Well now is as good as any time I should think,” said the hare, and bounded off up the path.
 
A hare is a hare after all, and a little girl is a little girl, so you can imagine it was difficult for Goldilocks to keep up; in fact it wasn’t long before the hare had disappeared into the distance.
 
Puffing and panting, Goldilocks eventually arrived at the front door of the Three Bear’s cottage. Just as she arrived, Daddy Bear opened the door.
 
“Good morning Goldilocks,” said Daddy Bear with a smile. “You are very prompt, but you seem to be quite out of breath.”
 
“Indeed I am Daddy Bear,” she spluttered, “but tell me please, has Mr Hare passed this way?”
 
“As a matter of fact I saw him only about five minutes ago. He said something quite curious – now what was it? Ah yes, he said, "please tell the young lady I fulfilled the first part of my promise", though I’m sure I don’t know what he meant.”
 
Just as Daddy Bear finished speaking there was a commotion from behind and looking round they saw the hare, about a hundred feet away, pounding up the path that Goldilocks had just trodden. He staggered to a halt beside the cottage and after catching his breath he said: “And that’s the second part of my promise, because as you can see, I arrived here after you.”
 
“That’s remarkable,” offered Goldilocks, but you really must tell me Mr Hare how you managed such a thing. Was it by magic?”
 
“Alas,” said the hare, “I am no magician, but rather a child of the Enlightenment and for that reason I will tell you how I achieved this amazing paradox.
 
Being a hare, it wasn’t too difficult for me to lose you on the path, so you were nowhere to be seen when I arrived here the first time. Mr Bear was fortunately in the front garden, so I asked him to be sure to tell you that I had kept the first part of my promise. The second part of my strategy relied on the fact that you seemed to be a good girl, and I estimated that you would always do what your mother told you. Is that correct?”
 
“Oh yes,” said Goldilocks, nodding vigorously.
 
“And I also thought it very likely that your mother would have told you that when you walk through the forest, you should always stick to the wide and well trodden path, for fear of wild animals?” He nodded in the direction of Daddy Bear, “Begging your pardon Sir?”
 
“That’s very true,” admitted Goldilocks, “I never stray from the path. Two of my friends, Hansel and Gretel once did that and they were very nearly eaten by a wicked witch.”
 
“Just so,” said the hare. “And that being the case I thought it unlikely you would know about the much smaller path, over there beyond the trees. It follows the same line as this wide path and actually joins it about half a mile back in the direction from which we came. All I had to do, after alerting Daddy Bear, was to take that path in the opposite direction. By the time it merged with the big path, you had already passed, so I merely followed you and arrived behind you, as I had suggested I would. Of course you couldn’t see me going back because the trees hid me from you.”
 
Of course this is just a silly story but can we take anything from it? Perhaps we can. Maybe we can say:
 
·         Sometimes we don’t see what might otherwise be quite obvious, because the trees get in the way.
·         Not necessarily everything keeps going in the same direction.
·         There might be times when instead of the end justifying the means, the means are actually a consequence of the ends.
 

No comments:

Post a Comment